Both I think. Some angels (spiritual) and all humans (physical) rebelled against Jehovah's right authority! But honestly I don't see much difference between the physical and the spiritual. It's all illusion, reality are the spiritual ideas at play whether in spiritual or physical, between conscious minds [for example: whether physical or spiritual, lying is lying, and wrong - 'physical' simply presents impetus for sin according to body-related desire] So if this is settled once for all time in both 'realms' I think we can say (at least by inference) that this is the first and only rebellion against Jehovah's authority. (which to me, means there aren't other sentient minds in the 'physical' universe - since they would have rebelled as well, at some point) .... hmmmm, kinda sad that I just read "not to go beyond what is written" yesterday!!!!!
It's of benefit to keep in mind as it pertains to consciousness in this universe, that it didn't take humans long at all to establish themselves on this planet, create written language, then on to technology that takes them beyond this solar system. So Literally this universe could have the very scenarios you see in Star Trek within a few thousand years, nothing in time compared to the eons from the beginning of this universe to now.
Hi All: I may be misunderstanding what has been discussed, but you don't believe that Jesus' ransom was for any and all sentient life forms in the universe that may have sinned, do you? He was sent here to ransom Adam's sin. Frank
Hi Josh: You may know what you mean by post #16, but I sure don't, it seems contradictory to me. I am sure of my position on this issue, but I won't speak for y'all. Frank
I understand why Frank is not sure of what is being said. Having read post #16 by Joshuastone7, and posts by Singlecell, there appears to be some confusion between use of the word “consciousâ€, and “conscienceâ€. The state of conscious is quite different than conscience. If this discussion is to include realms other than this earth, we get into the area of philosophy. If you want to include areas other than human, you are speculating at best. If their are other universes, or multiverses, again, we are speculating. “If however consciousness is unique to this planet, . . .â€. This question addresses; being aware. That is what this word means. If a living being on this earth is unconscious, it in unaware of anything. Like the dead are conscious of nothing at all. (Ec. 9:5) So, consciousness just addresses being aware, being able to observe. It has nothing to do with moral decisions. You can be conscious and immoral. I'm also unsure if animals have a conscience. They are conscious. Conscience, on the other hand, requires knowledge. With knowledge comes choices, which involves thoughts, desires, intentions; feelings. This knowledge is "within oneself, sense of right, a moral sense". Paul addressed this in his letter to the Romans, “For when people of the nations, who do not have law, do by nature the things of the law, these people, although not having law, are a law to themselves. They are the very ones who demonstrate the matter of the law to be written in their hearts, while their conscience is bearing witness with them, and by their own thoughts they are being accused or even excused.†(Ro. 2:14-15) The English word conscience comes from the Greek suneidesis, which Paul uses in the scripture. There is also a distinction between “conscious†and “conscienceâ€. The Greek word for conscious is heautou, and is translated as meaning himself, herself, themselves, etc. “And some of the scribes said to themselves, This fellow blasphemes.†(Mt. 9:3) “If Satan casts out Satan, he is divided against himself; how then will his kingdom stand?†(Mt. 12:26) I'll leave with this; Is Satan conscious, and does he have a conscience? Is he guilty of sin?
"Consciousness is the quality or state of self-awareness, or, of being aware of an external object or something within oneself. It has been defined as: sentience, awareness, subjectivity, the ability to experience or to feel, wakefulness, having a sense of selfhood, and the executive control system of the mind. Despite the difficulty in definition, many philosophers believe that there is a broadly shared underlying intuition about what consciousness is. As Max Velmans and Susan Schneider wrote in The Blackwell Companion to Consciousness: "Anything that we are aware of at a given moment forms part of our consciousness, making conscious experience at once the most familiar and most mysterious aspect of our lives." Wikipedia
'Self aware' would be a more appropriate term than 'conscious', I'm sorry I didn't clarify that when making a point about 'lying' which is indeed a conscience matter. Animals are conscious, but not self aware, at least to the point of being able to manifest a conscience. An animal cannot sin against Jehovah or anything else, because they don't know law, etc. (though in my experience that may be false ... lol, I'm pretty sure my dog sins against me ... ) But Satan is both conscious and has a conscience. Angels / Humans / Jehovah / Jesus and perhaps my pug are the only known conscious beings with a conscience So the question of universal sovereignty deals only with a mind capable of conscience, in my thinking. And this issue will be resolved in finality for all past, present and future conscience bearing minds.
So, this begs a thought experiment. Would there be any need for animals here on this planet without humans? Of what purpose would a planet serve with just animals? So therefore the animals need conscious humans with consciences, for can it not be said that without us, the universe ceases to exist? That's actually a fundamental aspect of String Theory. However, to simplify, there is no reason to have animals if there is no conscious being with a conscience along with them. Therefore said animals have no rights in the question of sovereignty and obviously not the entities spoken of in my posts. There is no need to even discuss animals as it pertains to Jehovah and Jesus acts here on earth. There will never be a need for life on a planet without a conscious being made up of the elements of this universe and able to know Jehovah to experience it.
I agree with your sentiment Joshua! I've heard it said that 'the earth is more important than mankind' It's the complete opposite! Man is aware of our place in the universe and can know the creator. Without the ability to recognize the creation, it has less meaning. It would be a machine (a truly amazing machine), rather than something spiritual. This is the beautiful gift Jehovah gave us, and we spit in his face over simple and righteous rules of behavior, which must exist for there to be peace in the creation ...
So you think that Jesus' death settled the issue for Satan and the fallen angels too ? and that their sins are like the humans' sins ?
The animals follow one law only, their instinct. They can't violate it. They don't have the choice. The intelligent and perfect (that is not defective) beings like the humans or the angels are the only creatures who are able to go beyond the limits decided by Jehovah. They had a choice, the choice not to do it. Adam and Eve, Satan and his demons had the choice not to cross that limit. They chose to "sin"*. We, as imperfect humans, don't have the choice. We sin even though we don't want to, which is why Jesus' sacrifice applies to us. Adam and Eve suffered from that deliberate choice. They had been warned and they were treated accordingly. Justice was meted out. Their offsprings suffer from it too but they didn't choose to be that way. We didn't make the choice to get into Sin by sinning wilfully but we have the opportunity to get outta there thanks to Jesus' sacrifice and in this case, the choice is yours to make. The name of that choice is : faith. * I put it between quotation marks because I want here to make a distinction between our kind of Sin and theirs.
I dont understand how this would mean that there is no other intelligent biological life out there. Is it not possible that they simply made the choice that Adam and Eve did not....To Obey? Why must we reason from the point of view that well...if we sinned, then other intelligent biological creatures would have done so as well? I would like to think that at least theres ONE PLANET that actually got it right the first time.
The question really isn't about what the universe was created for. Without a doubt the universe was created to hold countless life forms that would have the ability to know Jehovah. The question is the level of the act of Jesus coming to this planet to be born as a human, live a life in an imperfect world, then give that faithful life up in behalf of mankind. The extent of what that gift was denotes the idea that this act was once and for all for all conscious life with a conscience that will ever exist in the universe. The question raised in the garden was right to rule. Now if there is currently intelligent life elsewhere in the universe it could be said that Jesus's act only applies to this planet. That would lesson what was given. No, in fact what Jesus gave was for all life, on all planets in all the universe. This subject can never be raised again. So with that said it denotes with a high degree of probability that this planet must be the only spot currently with intelligent life, and able to know Jehovah at this given moment. Another thing that has to be very clear, whether you think other planets hold intelligent life or not it must be well understood that this planet is the only planet in the universe that sin is present in. Now with that said the odds of just so happening to being born on this one planet among trillions of billions of other worlds would be astronomical... Now also, why would Satan have chosen this planet? Because he happen to be here at that moment? Do you think if he tried to get other planets to sin that Jehovah would have just let him roam the universe tempting planets? Or would you be saying Satan succeed on his first try? In fact the evidence from all angles shows that with a high rate of probability that earth is currently the only planet in the universe supporting intelligent life able to know Jehovah. Think of what position this planet will hold in the universe after the end of this mess? It would be a mythical Shangri-la among all other worlds, as the first and last in this universe.
Awesome points, there Joshua and thanks for the clarity and patience for reasoning with me. I suppose theres just an deep inner yearning for at least some distant planet to have actually gotten it right the first time and that perfection, beauty , and Godly devotion is being practiced the way it was meant to be by fleshly organisms. One day, this will be all behind us and the earth will certainly hold a very special place in the eyes of God as well as future life on other planets.
We only have two pieces of evidence: 1. The angels 2. Mankind Both sinned Perhaps I'm wrong, but when I ponder these issues it seems that 'sin' is a natural occurrence in the self aware mind, whether physical or spiritual. Sin is the 'easy' way that without perfect instruction from the father, and patience, we have no hope of conquering. (edit: just read Joshua's post, very nice, I should have just left it there)
Oh I agree, Utuna Sometimes my dog seems to get mad about various things ("no, no walk today" or "gotta go, late dinner tonight"), and attempts to 'make me pay' by pooing on a rug. But it's me just being a goon (though the poo is real).
Darn it, SingleCell, now you just opened another can of worms for me. You mentioned a very important fact, ANGELS OF HEAVEN sinned. Even one that was apparently 'Top Notch' or....cream of the crop, whom we now know as "Satan". considering the fact that quite a few angels sinned, how perfect are they to begin with? Is "P E R F E C T I O N" relative as in some are more perfect than others or do they all share perfection to the exact same degree....or, are their varying degrees which would explain why some were more susceptible to the corrupting influence than others? Never, mind....It'll just bring up more questions that will keep up at night. God knows I have enough crap running around in my head as it is. Lol
This is a great point Gabriel, and we touched on it in another thread recently. "You must be perfect, as your Father in heaven is perfect" Does that mean literally flawless in behavior? NO!!! The context of Matthew 5:48 is that we must be perfectly forgiving, loving our enemies, as Jehovah is perfectly forgiving! It's an admission that we're going to continue messing up and NEED forgiveness from each other. Perfection isn't flawless behavior (for mankind at least) but rather the flawless approach to being sinned against. ----- Now, perhaps sometime down the road this is minimized to the point where we are *almost* perfect in behavior, but it ain't now, and it's not going to happen for the majority of us this side of Christ's kingdom!