Yes, I've noticed this pattern of behaviour many times - where they create a "problem" and there wasn't one there to start with. So they are then forced to create a "solution." My relatives are very down-to-earth. One of the rules we live by is: "if it ain't broken, we don't fix it." Wallflower
Hi Wallflower, I once read that "Hegelian Dialectict" create the problem, watch it manifests and then to come up with the solution, is the protocol which every government has used to gain control of the masses because it works every time. It makes the solution solver our hero's, we become dependent on them and rely on them for our every need. And your relatives have got the right moto which is my moto also
Here is the feeling I have when I read some posts out there on Internet from knowledge-centered ex-JWs...
OK its very plain that you know too much about mind control technology and how its used to properly milk you! that's why your called sheep. you give wool and milk and cluster in groups. just make sure that your Shepard is really a Shepard and not the butcher! sure theirs good food safety and shelter. but when the leader comes is that leader going to take wool milk? or will you go through the door and come out the other side in little white trays? that's what controlled thinking is all about keeping you happy and producing the maximum and giveing little more to you than an belief in a future reward in exchange for your service now! now nothing against the kingdom Hall or any other church. but Stalin Hitler Napoleon and ceaser all offered paradise utopia. if you would just perform this certain task for awhile! religion is the ultimate mind control scam! I dress up in a priest suit do some preaching promise you heaven if you obey and threaten you with hell if you don't! I drive a nice car and collect your money. you buy my church building with your donations 20 years latter and you have bought me all kinds of stuff and all I did was stand on the plateform and tell you good story's! hey you just can't do better!
Yeah, but do you mean that those who want to stay and who, despite all the blatant hypocrisy and hot air, see beautiful spiritual qualities and unfeigned love for God in their b/s and who have another idea of the kind of worship that they owe to their heavenly Father are stupid....? Are all the spiritually bamboozled people on the same side only ? If, according to what you just said, you don't seem to be willing to go fetch the stray sheep, who will go and fetch them ? Don't you think that Jehovah is able to raise shepherds like David was... for his beloved sheep's sake ? : "But Saul said to David: “You are not able to go against this Phi·lis′tine to fight with him, for you are but a boy, and he is a man of war from his boyhood.†And David went on to say to Saul: “Your servant became a shepherd of his father among the flock, and there came a lion, and also a bear, and [each] carried off a sheep from the drove. And I went out after it and struck it down and made the rescue from its mouth. When it began rising against me, I grabbed hold of its beard and struck it down and put it to death. Both the lion and the bear your servant struck down; and this uncircumcised Phi·lis′tine must become like one of them, for he has taunted the battle lines of the living God.†Then David added: “Jehovah, who delivered me from the paw of the lion and from the paw of the bear, he it is who will deliver me from the hand of this Phi·lis′tine.†At this Saul said to David: “Go, and may Jehovah himself prove to be with you.â€" - 1 Samuel 17:33-37
yes indeed who will go? you and me that's who! because if we don't we will all feel guilty that we did not and worry how much we displeased Jehovah. good or bad we have been trained to behave and feel that way. its like God and the devil good or bad still uses mind control and Evan the bible tells us that we who want to be Christians must take every thought captive. so it comes down to what will the controlled thinking be used for? to build or tear down?
Hi Utuna, And so He will - Jehovah will raise up true shepards to guide and direct those who love him - not wolves in sheeps clothing - not shepards that get fat and sell the sheep so that they will get rich. The Kingdom will be in the hands of chosen ones by Jehovah who wil be made incorruptible and immortal and will only make loving and proper decisions that affect the sheep for their good. It will be so wonderful - not what we see being done by the so-called faithful and discreet slave that will disfellowship you on a whim for disagreeing with them. Shalom and may you have a nice day. Joe
(opinion to follow) In the kingdom, yes! Now however is a time of 'sifting'. Think about it, Saul was wrong, wasn't he? And yet David didn't kill him when he had the chance. Similarly Jesus didn't slander Satan. Whether you think the GB are 'evil' or not, there is a lesson here. This is part of the sifting. Deep spiritual lessons, where first appearances are not accurate, and lessons are learned from repression and rule by false Kings. edit: this reasoning could be applied to the Catholic church, which I would disagree with, so it's a gray area ... hence, my opinion, and not a truth statement
Hi SingleCell, I do see your point and agree with your conclusion and agreement with Utuna that there are those who can now help the truly God loving brothers and sisters in the organization. That would be a gift of the spirit to be able to do that right? I tried for a couple of years but could not get past what the spirit was leading me to do. Once out in a disfellowshipped state there is not much left to do except join in on sites like this one and try to encourage ones that are coming out of the organization to not lose their faith and trust in Our Father and His Dear Son. May Jehovah give you wisdom and strength to endure on helping who you can. Joe
No, you didn't ! You hit several nails on the head ! What you said is awesome ! What would an ex-JW have done if he had been in the Good Samaritan's shoes....? Let the Jew die....? Or let him suffer long enough so he learns the lesson...? I'm telling you, spiritually speaking, most of both the JWs and the ex-JWs in such a situation would have thought twice before reaching out a helping hand, unconditionally.... That's not what Jesus taught ! Knowledge is a good slave but a bad master. What I'm going to say is a general statement : For God's sake, didn't our Lord say enough to get the sense of it, to get a deeper understanding of things ? That's beyond me !
Hi Utuna, Thanks for the reply - I am thinking that most of us here wish to turn attention to Jehovah and Jesus and not ourselves. We love truth that comes from them and want to share with each other what little tidbits have been granted to us by the Father. Have a blessed day. Joe
Hi Joe, There's nothing to forgive, you said it as it is. I think everyone on this forum have good intentions, but have been emotionally affected by past experiences associated with the organisation. I think as things unfold and prophesy becomes clearer as to the time span we are in. We will all have choices to make, the celestial chariot is moving fast and we just have to make sure we are moving with it and try not to let satan use circumstances and situations blur our vision. I know I for one get's very emotional when I feel somethings unjust, but I have to also realise Jehovah allows these things as tests.
Joe I've always love your posts, you are NOT an 'ex-JW', but a well balanced and loving Christian. A true Jehovah's Witness. There is a gap between the organizations idea of a 'true Christian' and the reality. Merely being 'associated' with the WTBS does not a Jehovah's Witness make. So you are pursuing your ministry as a service to Jehovah and his Son, bearing witness to their magnificence and sovereignty, and helping others to find them (or stay with them). We make ourselves idolaters to correlate being an official "Jehovah's Witness" with being a true Christian. We're on the same page my friend, truth is greater than falsehood, and when you speak truth you cannot offend those who pursue truth.
Hi All, Thanks a lot for your reply's - it really means a lot to me. Being looked at as a outcast by those I truly love has been very hard sometimes. I appreciate that you brothers and sisters see that all I really want is to give praise and credit to Jehovah thru His Son and their living word of truth. Have a blessed day. Joe
I'm confused. What lesson would the ex-JW be trying to teach the Samaritan? To say that 'most' would think twice sounds pretty cynical. In fact being a JW, or ex-JW doesn't have anything to do with it. It comes down to human compassion which everybody has the ability to possess. Anybody can be a witness of Jehovah, whether they've been a JW, are a JW, or have never been a JW. Point is you don't have to be a Jehovahs Witness to be a witness of Jehovah. The statement 'Knowledge is a good slave but a bad master' is a bit ambiguous as it really depends on the knowledge doesn't it? Knowledge can be a great master, it just depends on what the knowledge is of. Proverbs 9:10 “. . .The fear of Jehovah is the start of wisdom, and the knowledge of the Most Holy One is what understanding is. . .†IF we apply 'Knowledge is a good slave but a bad master' to JW's today, what do we find? Knowledge of what? Some truth, some lies, alot of misunderstanding dealing with the scriptures which can only lead to a bad conclusion when they refuse to stop whitewashing what the society is doing. If the original congregation of God, the Israelites, failed to stand up for true knowledge, what can we expect to happen to those today who do the same? What lesson can we learn from them? Isaiah 5:13 “. . .Therefore my people will have to go into exile for lack of knowledge. . .â€
I appreciate your posts, and can completely understand what you are feeling. It certainly feels like a wilderness does it not? Only God can judge a true heart, but from my own perspective your sincerity seems to be worn on your sleeve. Thanks for the posts, and hang in there... patience is a virtue.
Hi Cristo, Thanks for your thoughts and reply. I can guarntee you that I do not wear my feelings on my sleeve. In Fact just the opposite. I really do believe that I belong to Jehovah. And He is my refuge and my God in whom I trust. I in no way put my trust in men or do I need the approval of any man or organization. Like yourself I will stand alone before Jehovah and he will conduct my legal case. I consider it a privelege to be able to speak with freedom of speech on this and other forums about the things the spirit has led me to believe. May you have peace and a nice day. Joe
Hello...I didn't say your feelings, I said your sincerity. To wear it on your sleeve means it is obvious to me. Sorry if I wasn't clear.
It is in my opinion a true statement. Jehovah doesn't allow the Truth to be known for a reason. There's no perfect religion or one that would be true in everything. Is it but a mere coincidence ? If someone can show us a religion that would be more truthful than the JWs, then let's all join it ! There's none ! Does it make sense to remain on our own devices either ? Is knowledge what matters only ? Isn't the messy faith that so many people have out there on internet a proof enough that waiting for an hypothetical epiphany is a dream ? Why the need to stress so much on the importance of the elders and to "keep holding the pattern of healthful words" if all Christians are unerringly taught by Holy Spirit ? If knowledge isn't the magic wand that so many people extol here and there, doesn't it mean that something else is very important too ? Many religious leaders who were not approved anymore by Jehovah were still used by him for His purpose's sake and Holy Spirit spoke through them : "This, though, he did not say of his own originality; but because he was high priest that year, he prophesied that Jesus was destined to die for the nation, and not for the nation only, but in order that the children of God who are scattered about he might also gather together in one." - John 11:51-52 "Then E′li answered and said: “Go in peace, and may the God of Israel grant your petition that you have asked of him." - 1 Sam. 1:17 "And Paul said: “Brothers, I did not know he was high priest. For it is written, ‘You must not speak injuriously of a ruler of your people.’â€" - Acts 23:5 Both Hannah and Paul remained respectful, even though they had good reasons to retort. Obviously, that doesn't mean that we shouldn't speak out. I don't think that the people of Israel ignored and didn't complain about Eli's sons, that Hannah ignored it when Eli sent her packing, and yet, she replied respectfully. Paul knew as well that there are limits to outspokenness... "Beloved ones, do not be puzzled at the burning among YOU, which is happening to YOU for a trial, as though a strange thing were befalling YOU." - 1 Pe 4:12